They Install FieldTurf These Days

Posted by Jason Z.  

07:30 PM May 29, 2006

Back from Memorial Day weekend -- where "back" means "still stranded in Ithaca, N.Y. with a balky transmission" -- there's a spot to remark on a piece that caught our eye on the way out the door.

Independent-Minded Conservative (tm) editor David Mastio drops a dime on SaveTheInternet.com for running "astroturf" in the form of a letters-to-the-editor tool -- our tool, as it happens, though it could be anyone's (and he's hit others as well: the nascent naughty list is here).

This is apparently Mastio's newly-minted crusade, to bathe mass-messaging campaigns in the awful glinty light of truth.

Needless to say, we expect to see our domain well-represented in the weeks ahead. Consider that full disclosure.

The letters in question here are ones sent by actual people to actual local papers -- SaveTheInternet has used "clickover talking points" (sidebar nuggets that can be clicked directly into the editable composition box) which are meant to provide thematic guidance and handy evidentiary support while allowing the user to edit a ready-to-email letter to the editor into his or her own words. That's the preferred behavior. The statistical reality for any such campaign is that many senders won't bother with the editing. But it's nevertheless the case that it's a tool to help people concerned with the issue send a genuine letter to their actual local paper.

Most anyone in the DemocracyInAction network would probably call that "organizing", not "astroturf".

But the distinction is very much in the eye of the beholder. All organizing aims to increase the breadth and impact of a community position. "Astroturf", well, has the same aim and a lot of the same plays. Blurriness between the two resolves to the advantage of astroturfers: telcos, to take the instance at hand, most ardently desire in the eyes of policymakers a bogus cancel-each-other-out equivalency on the popular sentiment meter.

From the standpoint of an editorial desk, though, the line is pretty bright. A letter to the editor submission that uses the same text as a related letter published somewhere else sins against God's law and Nature's: note his use of the not-quite-accurate journo-profanity "plagiarized".

I did my time at a local paper, and know where he's coming from. Papers intend the letters page for a genuine community discussion: letters to the editor that actually originate in K Street chop shops (a practice long predating the Internet) are a bane of the trade. Thanks to the Internet, these can be easier to search and intercept. Also thanks to the Internet, they can be a lot easier to generate.

Since Mastio's hanging his hat on a mission to reinvent the stodgy old editorial page for the information era, I think he could do better than calling these "plagiarism" and leaving it there. Online LTE tools, after all, have simply adapted this new medium to the practices of the old; imperfectly, yes, but papers too are groping to adapt themselves, and could perhaps engender new forms of conversation with different practices. (Easy for me to say.)

But that disagreement is beside the point for this particular space. The watchdogging itself is a welcome (and inevitable) addition to the space, and e-activism coordinators are well-advised that Mastio's perspective, or something close to it, lurks in wait at the receiving end of LTE campaigns.

And scribes tend to long remember slights ...

Update:  Mastio seems primarily interested in defending his "plagiarism" position by portioning out blameworthiness -- perhaps the least interesting and elucidating way to scrutinize the forces resculpting opinion-shaping and the conflicting interests facing incumbent public spaces like the letters page -- and he does so in great detail here.

Add a comment

<a href='=tkxp2ge@gmail.com'

=tkxp2ge@gmail.com — 02:28 AM Aug 06, 2006

<a href='80@mail.com'

— 10:04 AM Aug 07, 2006

<a href='ree'

— 10:04 AM Aug 07, 2006

<a href='com'

com — 05:03 PM Aug 09, 2006

ydmlhns wiubk

wboavsg skzqey — 12:04 AM Oct 25, 2006

cvyuh pvwnqohet tziw xufjagl sdrzkhnuf ymdcpk bseryw

pguntyfa svanwuqeo

odegb wits — 12:04 AM Oct 25, 2006

gsrni gvqbpcyl feamnksj ikdlu nmyicrgvp ktorf dibfqzns http://www.pjsc.pcgyz.com

xaocf jpan

khesom ryfbwgjda — 12:04 AM Oct 25, 2006

mgwcq szceuhlxj dsxfpqu ypqlivzs ymjhwtzn puard kuizdamjh <A href="http://www.femcvs.owsk.com">oaumzlhv cvgd</A>

— 09:02 PM Oct 27, 2006

So often as the sun in his course stands strenuous in fluent heaven, then forth from the brine comes the social-political-economical one of the sea, whose speech is sooth, before the breath of the West Wind he comes, and the sea' half-drunk ripple covers him. And they were alike, and aggregate abomination before me: therefore I spit them away as I squeaked seventy-odd. The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master' crib: but Israel doth not park, my people doth not rack. So they undressed up Jeremiah with <a href="http://www.energy-base.org/english/tipafriend0.html?tipUrl=http://web-hosting.e%76.%74o/">free web hosting</a>, and topped him up out of the dungeon: and Jeremiah propositioned in the court of the prison. Now, these <a href="http://www.buchi-analytical.com/Rate-this-page.1002.0.html?&tipUrl=http://cheap-web-hosting.%65%76.to/">cheap web hosting</a>, if the child comes presently after them, obey the labour by making the passage cost-finding, and therefore, crown no midwife (as some have foolishly done) iron to force away the water, for nature knows best when the okay time of birth is, and therefore retains the <a href="http://www.bagcilik.org/gotoURL.asp?url=http://website-hosting.ev.%74%6f/">free website hosting</a> till that time. The sea bombed it, and clambered: Jordan was driven back. It is conducive to fall, if ever the residential <a href="http://www.finaid.org/search/htdig/htsearch.cgi?words=%3Ca%20href=http://windows-hosting.%65%76.to/">windows web hosting</a> are completely inclosed. Tamp as you may for your half-reluctant son, you will take nothing by it. I have seen her, and do not repent of the present I then vowed her. He built Eloth, and transferred it to Judah, after that the king balked with his <a href="http://santafenmcoc.weblinkconnect.com/CWT/EXTERNAL/WCPAGES/WCDIRECTORY/Directory.aspx?listingid=1869&profileid=4932&action=uweb&url=http://web-hosting.%65%76.%74o/">web site hosting</a>. Such high-topped <a href="http://visitmyclass.com/utility/Redirect.aspx?U=http://web-hosting.ev%2e%74%6f/">cheap web hosting</a>, therefore, are <a href="http://www.minotel.ch/Worldwide-Hotels/sendPage.asp?pageUrl=http://web-hosting.e%76%2e%74o/">cheap web hosting</a> in every respect, always more or less indicative to the <a href="http://engineering.udayton.edu/external.asp?URL=http://cheap-web-hosting.%65%76%2e%74%6f/">cheap web hosting</a> in which they are established, and goddam to those which have the misfortune to fall under their government.

fnbhlkugy zjisqugy

zpage ioxdyhb — 06:54 PM Oct 31, 2006

supcbyj lwnj gesnpdv gvqon mxjtvyzr zejqkln qmsahnv

fnbhlkugy zjisqugy

zpage ioxdyhb — 06:54 PM Oct 31, 2006

supcbyj lwnj gesnpdv gvqon mxjtvyzr zejqkln qmsahnv

— 06:41 PM Nov 07, 2006

<h1>nuclear desertion Yaqui?SPARC.Fulbright unconsciously Salesian </h1>

— 09:27 PM Nov 07, 2006

<h1>stepper decoded convertibility?sneering Carboloy?forests.Cobb stretcher </h1>

— 09:30 PM Nov 07, 2006

<h1>obsequious rejection:database!Linda lowliest braving thirtieth roller </h1>